Production services

Strategic Communication

Insights and analytics

When should we expect more from our audience?

White House correspondent Maggie Haberman said something on her book tour that stopped me in my tracks. She described how the people around President Trump have learned to brief him visually. He has little appetite for long briefing books and wants to see what things looked like rather than read written accounts. Haberman’s observation was that a steady diet of images can keep you reacting, especially when what you’re shown keeps confirming the view you already hold.

While I’ve thought about the political implications, I’ve spent more time thinking about how often I see a version of this at work. I’m regularly asked to turn months of analysis or planning into a few slides for a leadership team. I like that work and like to think I am good at it and I’m a big believer in making the point as simply as possible. Sometimes these presentations are built to persuade or appease or confirm “nothing to see here;” but sometimes the audience is being asked to commit resources or adjust a budget. When are we doing ourselves a disservice by condensing the story into the most palatable version of itself? When should we ask more of the people in the room?

In one of my first blog posts, I wrote about my Golden Retriever Rule. The idea, borrowed from a line in Margin Call, was that you should be able to explain your point so simply that even a golden retriever could follow it. I still think about that when I’m halfway through a brand plan and wondering what, precisely, the team wants anyone to take away.

I wonder how much of what we do on social media has crept into our organisations. We’ve become so good at serving up social media-sized, calorie-dense snacks for an external audience that we now do it by default for colleagues whose judgment we need. And we’re better off when those colleagues interrogate the story. They get the headline, the strongest chart and a story that hangs together. The messy bit that might sharpen the discussion is often the first thing we cut.

If we’re asking someone to make a consequential decision, they may need to know how representative that story is, what the evidence can bear and which trade-offs they’re accepting. That takes a little more of their time and attention and sometimes it’s entirely reasonable to ask for it.

I’m often brought in to help a team identify their red thread through a brand plan or a senior leadership presentation. They are trying to weave together disparate datasets, the perspectives of several functions, and the needs of stakeholders inside and outside the organisation. Even a seasoned team can get so close to the detail that an outside perspective helps them see the story running through it. It’s a hard skill to master and by the mere fact of being an outsider, I have an advantage of seeing through the noise.

Once we’ve found the red thread, we can use it to guide people through the evidence. A chart might show a pattern buried in a spreadsheet. Sometimes a white paper, a detailed dataset, or an interesting analysis stitching together two pieces of data requires your audience to pause, consider, digest, and then respond.

In 2006, education researchers Matthew McCrudden, Gregory Schraw and Kendall Hartley, all at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, published a study in The Journal of Experimental Education. Giving readers a clear idea of what to pay attention to improved what they learned from a text without increasing reading time. I think about that when I’m preparing a leadership pre-read. If you want people to get to grips with the detail, start by telling them what you need their judgment on. McCrudden, Schraw and Hartley

I think of this as intelligent compression. You cut the detail that gets in the way and keep what people need to follow your reasoning and challenge it. If an inconvenient number could change the decision, it belongs in the briefing.

Here’s my amendment to the Golden Retriever Rule. Before you decide how simple to make it, ask what do you need from who is in the room. If you want their wisdom, their support, their advice or a decision, you owe them the information they need to give you something back. A glossy puff piece only gets you so far.

There’s a reason we call them senior leadership teams. They’re smart, experienced and perfectly capable of digesting a few pages. It’s infantilising to assume they need everything served up in bites. They can tell when you’re skating over details or hiding inconvenient discrepancies. Give them the two datasets that disagree, and someone in the room may have seen that pattern before. Show them the assumption your recommendation depends on, and they might spot the one thing that would make it fall over.

When do we let truth get in the way of a good story? When it might change the decision. Give them the version you’d want to read if it were your decision to make.

A silhouette of a woman with a ponytail against a pink and blue background

Production Stills

For experts and organisations with knowledge worth turning into high-quality content.

For experts and organisations with knowledge worth turning into high-quality content.

A suite of produced content can help educate your audience, market your product, or lift team engagement.

A suite of produced content can help educate your audience, market your product, or lift team engagement.